There is a reason, or rather, several reasons, why apprenticeship programs are so rare in small and medium-sized businesses (SMBs). Unfortunately, nearly all of them revolve around that old Reagan-era adage of the nine most terrifying words in the English language, “I’m from the government, and I’m here to help”. Apprenticeship was commandeered during the FDR New Deal era politics, when the National Apprenticeship Act established requirements around these formal training programs. Law creation most often comes from a good place, an area of agreement from large parts of a population with varying interests; however, law requires enforcement and enforcement requires documentation, and documentation breeds bureaucracy. Apprenticeships had been simple handshake agreements between an expert and a young trainee for centuries, but now in the era of union power and distrust of capital, those handshake agreements simply were not sufficient.

So then we return to today: very few SMB’s have formal apprenticeship programs. Truthfully, few large corporations do either, and then we wonder why the craftsman skills of old are so few and far between. It becomes a choice for a small business that is economically clear in the short term. Expend a non-trivial amount of time and money to train future workers that are well-rounded generalist experts in their field or build out SOPs that simplify processes for low wages and high turnover. Let others train and extract the value that exists for as long as you can. A small business doesn’t even know if it will exist in 2 years; how could we expect one to invest in an expensive 4-year training program?

But that short-term calculation may become harder to justify as AI takes over more routine work. A small business may be able to do more with fewer people, but those people will need the judgment to catch mistakes, solve unfamiliar problems, and understand how their work affects the rest of the business. Those abilities take experience to develop. If we automate the tasks that once gave beginners that experience, where will the next generation of capable workers come from? Apprenticeship offers a way to deliberately build that capability, provided the training fits the realities of running a small business. The question, then, is how to build a program a business can afford to start and sustain when the administrative burden makes the cost-benefit analysis so worrisome.

A New Apprenticeship Golden Age

The primary components of apprenticeship include On-The-Job Training hours, Related Technical classroom instruction, and Mentorship feedback. That’s it. The problem lies in the production and documentation of these standards. Governments like to read these standards in a very specific consultant language; there are requirements that union leaders and bureaucrats agreed to anywhere from 2 weeks to 20 years ago. Sometimes it changes. There are innumerable middlemen, consultants, colleges, and trade schools that all have some value to the bureaucracy but can appear to have less value to the employer. However, the truth is that they will be the key to the establishment of this next golden age of apprenticeship.

What if the employer could return to the handshake agreement of the past while still protecting the rights of the apprentice? It would require a commitment from the employer, but a commitment that is different from what is asked of them today. Today, the commitment resides in the ability to navigate a convoluted process and understand complex terminology and spend considerable amounts of money on tuition and training materials. The commitment I am proposing is an actual commitment in the individual. A deeply humanist agreement to provide actual feedback on the quality of work. Actual mentorship. Because the “How-to” guides have never been cheaper, knowledge will be replaced with experience. And Experience needs to be as accessible as college was in the early 2000s and 2010s.

What SME’s say Works

For my doctoral research, I interviewed representatives from 11 small and medium-sized businesses, along with three workforce development organizations and apprenticeship intermediaries. When asked what other employers should know before starting a program, participants repeatedly returned to the investment in the individual. Treat apprentices well. Give them regular feedback. Recognize their progress, and make sure the owner or senior leadership is actually committed to their development. One healthcare employer described buying caps and gowns and inviting families to a graduation ceremony because their apprentices deserved recognition for what they had accomplished. These were the everyday decisions employers believed helped people stay, learn, and see a future within the company.

The practical advice was equally direct. Build the curriculum around the skills the job actually requires. Instructional time is limited, so be deliberate about what you ask an apprentice to study. Recruit people who are willing to learn and can grow within the business, rather than relying entirely on prior credentials or experience. And get help. This is where the value of those outside organizations becomes clear. Participants described intermediaries helping turn their training plans into acceptable program standards, workforce boards helping navigate funding, and instructional partners helping align classroom learning with the job. They also advised planning for funding beyond the initial launch and choosing a recordkeeping system the business could realistically maintain. The employer still had to invest, but they did not have to figure out every piece alone.

One realization that did not make it into my report became the foundation of my business: employers could provide their own Related Technical Instruction. Essentially, a business could build its own trade school, with curriculum tailored to its work while still meeting the applicable program requirements. Think about what that makes possible. Classroom instruction could directly prepare an apprentice for the work they would perform that week. The employer could connect the explanation, the practice, and the feedback instead of trying to coordinate disconnected pieces of training. Developing that instruction would still take time and expertise, but the opportunity to remove duplication, improve relevance, and streamline the process was what led me to build CraftED. My responsibility as a researcher was to look across those experiences and ask what they meant together.

What It Takes to Sustain an Apprenticeship.

In all of my research and experience helping companies build programs, the most important element of building and maintaining an apprenticeship program as a small business is to want to do it. Not because you think it will save you money in the long run, not because you think it will reduce turnover, not because you want to improve relationships within your business, not because you want to be a leader in your community, but actually because of ALL of those things at the same time. You have to have a zealous belief that what you are doing is right. There are many things in life that can be done with low effort, but relationships aren’t one of them. And apprenticeships are relationships, plain and simple. If there is not someone on your team who believes wholeheartedly in that relationship, it will fail.

Second, get help. You are good at your job. Let people who are good at theirs build your program. I’m a football fan, and I’ve seen how the best players in the world can’t win with bad playcalling, and the best scheme in the world can’t win with bad players. As the owner of your business, you are the coach; but as a mentor for an apprenticeship, you’re the quarterback. If you do both well, then you have the makings of a real contender in your field.

Finally, think beyond the apprentice’s first job assignment. You are investing in someone who can eventually understand how the work fits together, solve problems without waiting for you, and teach the next person who walks through the door. That honestly takes time; they need to see multiple responsibilities and how those responsibilities tie together, and there needs to be room to make mistakes and get feedback. The return grows as the employee becomes capable of contributing in more ways and the business becomes less dependent on any one person, including you. Someone has to believe in the program enough to get it started, but its future cannot depend on that person being there forever. Over time, today’s apprentices should become tomorrow’s mentors.

Building the standards, curriculum, and progression that make that possible is the next step.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *